7 Signs Your Digital Marketing Agency Isn't Working

If your digital marketing agency isn’t delivering results, it’s time to evaluate their performance. Here are 7 warning signs to watch for:

• Flat or Dropping Website Traffic: Your agency should drive qualified visitors to your site. Declines in traffic could signal poor SEO, ineffective campaigns, or technical issues.
• Low Conversion Rates Despite Higher Ad Spend: If spending more doesn’t lead to better conversions, it’s a sign of poor targeting, weak landing pages, or ineffective strategies.
• Missing or Confusing Reports: Reports should clearly explain ROI, campaign performance, and next steps. Vague or delayed updates are red flags.
• Poor Communication: Delayed responses, unclear answers, or inconsistent messaging show a lack of coordination and focus.
• No Clear ROI: If your agency can’t demonstrate how their work improves revenue or reduces costs, your budget might be wasted.
• High Turnover or Changing Account Managers: Constant staff changes disrupt campaigns, waste time, and lead to inconsistent results.
• Generic Strategies: A one-size-fits-all approach ignores your business’s unique needs, limiting your potential for growth.

Quick Overview of Red Flags

If your agency shows one or more of these signs, it’s time to reassess. A reliable agency should provide clear communication, measurable results, and strategies tailored to your business goals.

How To Spot A Bad Marketing Agency Before It's Too Late

Sign 1: Website Traffic Is Flat or Dropping

Flat or declining website traffic is often a red flag that something in your strategy isn’t working. A good agency should focus on bringing in qualified visitors through a mix of SEO, paid advertising, social media, and content marketing. Consistent traffic isn’t just about numbers - it’s essential for generating leads, driving sales, and building awareness for your brand.

Here’s a reality check: the median website attracts about 20,000 unique visitors per month, and nearly half of surveyed businesses report monthly traffic between just 1,001 and 15,000. It’s no wonder that web traffic consistently ranks as one of the top measures of success in content marketing. But how do you keep tabs on these critical numbers?

How to Track Traffic Metrics

Tracking traffic metrics starts with using the right tools. Google Analytics, now in its GA4 format, is still the go-to for most businesses. With GA4, some familiar metrics have been renamed - for instance, "Bounce Rate" is now "Engagement Rate", and "Pages per Session" has become "Views per User". These updates may take some getting used to, but the insights they provide are invaluable.

Key metrics to monitor include:

• Unique visitors: How many individual users visit your site.
• New vs. returning visitors: A breakdown of first-time versus repeat traffic.
• Pages per session: How many pages users explore during a visit.
• Average session duration: How long visitors stay on your site.
• Traffic sources: Where your visitors are coming from - organic search, email, social media, etc..

These numbers go beyond simply showing how many people visit your site. They reveal how engaged those visitors are and which marketing efforts are driving results. For example, organic and email traffic sources often outperform others, with average conversion rates of 2.6% and 2.4%, respectively. Orbit Media’s analysis of 65 client websites found that organic search traffic had the highest engagement rate at 62.2%, compared to just 24.1% for paid social traffic. Agencies that monitor these metrics can adjust campaigns for maximum impact.

While Google Analytics is the industry standard, tools like HubSpot, Ahrefs, SEMrush, and Similarweb can provide additional insights into traffic trends and how your performance stacks up against competitors.

Warning Signs to Look For

Tracking metrics is one thing, but interpreting them is where the real work begins. Certain patterns can signal deeper problems. For instance, if your visitor numbers remain flat or decline over three to six months, it’s a sign your agency’s strategies may need a serious overhaul. Falling well below industry benchmarks or failing to grow over time points to ineffective execution.

A steady drop in organic traffic often highlights SEO issues. Your agency should focus on improving search engine rankings and expanding keyword visibility. Declines in this area might mean competitors are outranking you or that technical problems on your site remain unresolved.

Engagement metrics also tell a story. A bounce rate above 40% could mean visitors aren’t finding what they expected on your site. This is concerning because nearly two-thirds of websites maintain bounce rates below 40%. Similarly, websites that perform well tend to average session durations of 3 minutes, compared to just 54 seconds for underperforming pages. If users are leaving quickly, it could indicate poor audience targeting or ineffective landing pages.

Referral traffic is another area to watch. If your agency isn’t building strong partnerships or earning quality backlinks, you’re likely missing out on high-converting traffic that comes with greater trust and intent.

Lastly, pay attention to repeat visitor rates. Ideally, this should fall between 10% and 30%. A drop in this metric suggests your content isn’t engaging enough to bring visitors back.

Technical issues can also play a big role. High bounce rates and short session durations can stem from slow-loading pages or poor functionality. In fact, 42% of consumers say they’ll leave a website if it doesn’t function well, and bounce rates can more than double if a page takes over one second to load. Without addressing these technical problems, even the traffic your agency generates won’t convert effectively.

Sign 2: Low Conversion Rates Despite Higher Ad Spend

If your agency keeps asking for a bigger budget while your conversion rates refuse to budge, that’s a glaring issue. Businesses often pour more money into campaigns hoping for better outcomes, only to see their cost per acquisition climb while conversions remain frustratingly stagnant.

Here’s a simple example: if you increase your ad spend from $5,000 to $8,000 and your conversions only rise from 100 to 120, your cost per conversion jumps from $50 to $66.67. That’s not progress - it’s a clear sign something is off.

Knowing what qualifies as a reasonable conversion rate for your industry can help you identify when performance is falling short.

What Is a Good Conversion Rate?

Conversion rate benchmarks vary by industry. For instance:

• E-commerce: Typically between 2%–3%
• B2B: Often falls between 1%–3%
• Service-based businesses: Contact forms usually convert at 3%–5%

Organic and email traffic often perform better than paid channels. For simpler actions like email signups, conversion rates can climb to 10%–15%. On the other hand, high-ticket purchases may see rates dip below 1%. The key is to establish a baseline specific to your business and monitor trends over time.

If your agency has been running campaigns for several months and your conversion rates have either stagnated or declined - despite increased ad spend - that’s a major red flag. A capable agency should demonstrate steady improvements through testing, better targeting, and optimization.

Why Conversions Stay Low

When conversion rates fall short of expectations, several common issues could be at play:

• Poor audience targeting: If the agency is casting too wide a net or focusing on the wrong demographics, you’ll attract visitors who are unlikely to convert. Misaligned targeting wastes both time and money.
• Landing page issues: Even if your ads are driving traffic, a poorly designed landing page can derail conversions. Pages that don’t align with the ad’s promise, load too slowly, or confuse visitors with cluttered layouts will send prospects away in seconds.
• Weak calls-to-action (CTAs): If your CTAs are hard to spot, vague (e.g., “Learn More” instead of “Get Your Free Quote”), or poorly timed, potential customers won’t know what action to take next.
• Mobile optimization problems: With mobile devices accounting for over half of web traffic, a landing page that isn’t mobile-friendly can slash your conversion potential. If your agency isn’t prioritizing mobile usability, you’re leaving money on the table.
• Lack of trust signals: Missing elements like customer testimonials, security badges, clear contact details, or professional design can make visitors hesitate. B2B buyers, in particular, need to see credibility indicators before engaging.
• Timing and frequency missteps: Showing ads to people at the wrong stage of their buying journey - or bombarding them with excessive frequency - can push potential customers away instead of drawing them closer to a purchase.

Ultimately, a skilled agency should be able to pinpoint and fix these roadblocks. If your conversion rates aren’t improving despite higher ad spend, it’s a sign your agency either doesn’t have the expertise to address the issues or isn’t putting in the necessary effort to resolve them.

Sign 3: Missing or Unclear Reports

Accurate traffic metrics are essential, but clear and regular reporting is what truly helps you gauge your marketing performance. If your digital marketing agency isn't providing straightforward, consistent reports, consider it a red flag. Without transparent reporting, you're left guessing whether your marketing dollars are driving results - or just vanishing into thin air.

Agencies that struggle with performance often delay reports, overcomplicate them, or skip them entirely. This lack of transparency can be a sign that they aren't properly tracking results or are trying to obscure poor performance.

Think of it this way: an agency confident in their work will be eager to share their successes. If the reports are infrequent or overly confusing, it’s often a sign there’s not much good news to share.

Let’s dive into what a great report should include and why poor reporting can undermine your campaigns.

What Good Reports Should Include

A strong agency report should clearly outline your marketing performance without requiring you to decode complex data. The best reports combine clear metrics with actionable insights to guide your next steps.

Here’s what to expect from a quality report:

• ROI in clear dollar amounts: Instead of vague percentages, reports should show exactly how much return you’re getting on your investment.
• Conversion tracking: Details on leads, sales, or other key actions from each campaign are crucial. Metrics like cost per acquisition (CAC) reveal how much you’re spending to gain a new customer.
• Channel performance breakdowns: Reports should show which campaigns and platforms are delivering the best results. Visual aids like charts and graphs can help, but they need to be paired with clear explanations of what the numbers mean for your business.
• Forward-looking recommendations: Beyond showing past performance, great reports outline what’s next. Your agency should explain what adjustments they plan to make and how those changes will improve results.

Problems with Bad Reporting

Poor reporting can create serious obstacles for your business. When agencies provide vague summaries or focus on vanity metrics like impressions or clicks, it becomes impossible to make informed decisions about your marketing budget.

Missing reports often point to deeper accountability issues. If an agency isn’t tracking or communicating results regularly, they’re likely not optimizing your campaigns either. This can lead to wasted ad spend and missed chances to improve performance.

Overly technical reports are another problem. When data is buried in jargon or presented without context, it leaves you in the dark about your own marketing efforts. You shouldn’t need a marketing degree to understand if your campaigns are working.

Delayed or infrequent updates can also cost you. Imagine a campaign starts underperforming in January, but you don’t get a report until March. That’s two months of wasted budget that could have been reallocated to better strategies.

Perhaps the most frustrating issue is cherry-picked metrics. Some agencies highlight positive stats, like increased website traffic, while ignoring more critical metrics, like a drop in conversion rates. Without a full picture, you can’t truly assess whether your marketing investment is paying off.

If you find yourself confused or in the dark about your campaign’s results, your agency isn’t delivering. Reporting should empower you to make smart, informed decisions - not leave you wondering where your money went.

Sign 4: Poor Communication from Your Agency

Communication is the foundation of any strong agency-client relationship. Beyond just sharing metrics and reports, it ensures that your marketing strategy translates into real results. When a digital marketing agency fails to communicate effectively, it creates a chain reaction of issues - missed opportunities, wasted budgets, and campaigns that miss the mark.

Your agency is responsible for managing your brand's online presence and marketing budget. Without clear and consistent communication, how can you be confident they understand your priorities or are making decisions that align with your vision? A lack of transparency leaves you in the dark about how your marketing dollars are being spent.

Great marketing partnerships thrive on open dialogue and accountability. Poor communication, on the other hand, often points to deeper problems - whether it's disorganized processes, a lack of accountability, or a weak commitment to your success. Just as clear metrics are essential, so is straightforward communication to guide your strategy.

Let’s look at some common examples of communication failures.

Examples of Bad Communication

• Delayed responses: If your agency takes days - or even weeks - to respond to your inquiries, it’s a red flag. Marketing moves fast, and delays can leave you stuck waiting for answers about campaign performance or budget changes when you need them most.
• Vague answers: When you ask specific questions about your campaigns, you deserve clear, detailed responses. If your account manager regularly falls back on generic phrases like "we're on it" or "things look good" without offering specifics, they’re not providing the clarity you need.
• Unproductive meetings: Long meetings filled with industry jargon but lacking actionable insights are a waste of time. If you leave meetings feeling confused or if the same issues keep coming up without resolution, your agency isn’t communicating effectively.
• Inconsistent messaging: Conflicting information from different team members about your campaigns or budget can create confusion and erode trust. This kind of internal miscommunication often spills over into the quality of service you receive.

What Good Communication Looks Like

Strong communication from your agency involves several key practices:

• Regular, meaningful check-ins: A good agency schedules consistent meetings - whether weekly, bi-weekly, or monthly - and uses this time to go beyond surface-level updates. These sessions should focus on performance reviews, upcoming plans, and any necessary adjustments to your strategy.
• Proactive updates and timely responses: Quality agencies don’t wait for you to ask questions. They reach out when they identify opportunities, notice potential issues, or need to discuss budget changes. While not every inquiry requires an immediate answer, professional agencies acknowledge your messages quickly and provide realistic timelines for follow-ups.
• Clear, simple explanations: Marketing can be complex, but a great agency knows how to break it down. They explain technical data in a way that’s easy for you to understand, connecting the dots between what’s happening and why it matters for your business.
• Documented communication: To avoid misunderstandings, good agencies follow up on important discussions with email summaries, maintain shared documents for strategy updates, and clearly document agreements and decisions. This keeps everyone on the same page and ensures smooth progress.
• Results-focused communication: Instead of just listing activities, effective agencies focus on outcomes. They connect their actions to your business goals, discussing results in terms of revenue, lead quality, or long-term growth - not just clicks or impressions. This approach highlights how their efforts align with your vision.

When your agency communicates effectively, you stay informed and confident about your marketing efforts. You’ll understand not just what’s happening but also why decisions are being made and how they align with your goals. This level of transparency and clarity should be the standard, not the exception.

sbb-itb-cef5bf6

Sign 5: No Clear Return on Investment

When it comes to digital marketing, seeing a clear return on investment (ROI) isn't just a nice-to-have - it’s essential. ROI tells you whether your marketing dollars are actually driving results for your business. If your agency can’t show you clear evidence of ROI, it’s a red flag that your budget might be going to waste.

A reliable agency should clearly demonstrate how much revenue their efforts are generating and how that stacks up against what you’re spending. If they can’t connect the dots between your investment and tangible outcomes, something’s off.

Agencies that fail to prove ROI often lack strategic direction. They might keep you busy with campaigns that look impressive on the surface but fail to deliver meaningful results like sales, leads, or customer retention.

How to Measure ROI in Digital Marketing

Tracking ROI in digital marketing can get tricky, but focusing on key metrics can give you a solid understanding of your agency’s performance. One of the most telling metrics is Cost per Acquisition (CPA) - this shows how much you’re spending to acquire each new customer. For example, if you’re spending $50 to bring in a customer who generates $200 in profit, that’s a strong return. But if your CPA climbs to $150 while customer value stays the same, you’ve got a problem.

Another critical metric is Customer Lifetime Value (CLV), which estimates the total revenue you’ll earn from a customer over the course of your relationship. Comparing CLV to CPA gives you a clear sense of profitability. For instance, if your CLV is $500 and your CPA is $75, you’re earning about $6.67 for every dollar spent on acquisition - a ratio that most businesses would consider a win.

Revenue attribution is another important piece of the puzzle. This metric tells you which campaigns or channels are driving actual sales. A good agency should be able to break it down for you, showing how their email campaigns brought in $15,000 in sales last month or how Google Ads generated 47 new customers worth $23,500 in revenue. These insights show exactly where your money is working hardest.

Lastly, Conversion Rate Optimization (CRO) metrics reveal how effectively your agency is improving your marketing funnel. For example, if they’ve boosted your landing page conversion rate from 2.3% to 4.1% over six months, that’s a clear indicator of progress. More conversions from the same traffic mean more customers - and a direct impact on ROI.

These measurable metrics separate agencies that deliver results from those that don’t. The table below highlights the differences.

Good Agencies vs. Bad Agencies: Key Differences

A strong agency approaches your marketing budget like an investment portfolio. They constantly analyze which campaigns deliver the best returns and shift resources to maximize impact. For example, they might tell you that Facebook ads are bringing in leads at $42 each, while Google Ads are costing $67 per lead, and recommend reallocating your budget to get better results.

In contrast, underperforming agencies often treat marketing as a creative project rather than a business investment. They may celebrate a beautifully designed campaign that garners thousands of impressions but fail to explain how many of those impressions converted into paying customers - or whether the campaign was profitable at all.

The best agencies also understand that ROI can vary by timeline. They’ll set realistic expectations, acknowledging that strategies like SEO or content marketing might take months to show results, while paid advertising should yield quicker returns. Importantly, they won’t use long-term strategies as an excuse for poor short-term performance.

When ROI is clearly demonstrated, it changes the game. Instead of second-guessing whether your marketing spend is worth it, you’ll have the data to scale successful campaigns and cut underperforming ones. This level of transparency builds trust and ensures your budget fuels growth where it matters most.

Sign 6: High Turnover and Changing Account Managers

Few things disrupt your marketing efforts more than constantly adjusting to new account managers. If your agency has frequent staff turnover or a revolving door of clients, it’s a glaring red flag. High turnover creates instability that can derail your campaigns and hurt your results.

Every time a new account manager takes over, it’s like hitting the reset button. They need to get up to speed on your business, goals, and past performance. This adjustment period can take weeks, if not months, during which your campaigns may stall or lose direction. Meanwhile, you’re left re-explaining everything - again.

Frequent staff changes often point to deeper problems within the agency. High employee turnover can stem from poor management, overwhelming workloads, or low pay. These conditions drive skilled employees away, leaving behind either inexperienced hires or overburdened staff who struggle to deliver the attention your account deserves.

The fallout for your marketing strategy can be significant. Each new account manager brings their own style, which can lead to inconsistent messaging and disjointed campaigns. Your brand’s voice might shift unexpectedly, and effective strategies could be abandoned simply because the new manager lacks the necessary context.

Why High Client Turnover Spells Trouble

Agencies that frequently lose clients usually have one thing in common: they’re not delivering results. High client churn is like a performance review - unsatisfied clients leave, while happy ones stick around.

When an agency is constantly replacing lost clients, they often focus more on sales than on serving their current accounts. This shift in priorities can mean your account doesn’t get the strategic attention it needs, as the agency scrambles to bring in new business.

High client turnover can also lead to overpromising. Agencies desperate to secure new clients may make big promises they can’t keep, resulting in rushed work, missed deadlines, and cookie-cutter strategies that don’t align with your business.

You can often spot this issue by reviewing the agency’s case studies and testimonials. If their portfolio lacks evidence of long-term client relationships, it’s a sign of potential instability. Strong agencies proudly showcase partnerships that have lasted for years, reflecting their ability to consistently deliver value.

There’s also a financial ripple effect. Agencies losing clients may cut corners to save money - reducing investments in research, assigning junior staff to complex projects, or relying on automation instead of tailored strategies. While these measures might boost the agency’s bottom line, they can severely impact the quality of your campaigns.

Why Consistent Account Management Matters

Beyond client retention, stable account management is a cornerstone of effective marketing. Having the same account manager over time builds trust, deepens understanding, and improves results.

When an account manager works with you long-term, they develop a thorough understanding of your business, industry challenges, and customer behavior. This knowledge allows them to craft targeted campaigns, identify opportunities, and make quicker, more informed decisions. Instead of feeling like an outsider, they become an extension of your team.

A stable account manager also knows your company’s seasonal trends, understands which messages resonate with your audience, and can anticipate how new initiatives might perform. This familiarity leads to smoother communication, faster recommendations, and more strategic planning.

Long-term relationships simplify operations. You won’t have to repeatedly explain your business model, goals, or preferences. Your account manager already knows your budget constraints and can anticipate your needs, saving time and reducing the risk of miscommunication that could derail your efforts.

Agencies that prioritize employee satisfaction - through fair pay, professional development, and manageable workloads - tend to retain their staff. This stability benefits clients, as happy and secure account managers are more likely to go the extra mile for your campaigns.

Consistency also preserves your campaign history and data insights. Experienced account managers can spot trends and build on past successes, while newcomers might miss key details. This continuity ensures your marketing efforts remain optimized and aligned with your long-term goals.

When evaluating an agency, ask about their employee retention and average client relationship length. Reputable agencies should be able to share that most clients stay for years and that their account managers stick around long enough to develop meaningful partnerships. If they can’t provide this information - or seem hesitant to discuss it - it’s a strong indicator of potential instability that could disrupt your marketing efforts.

Sign 7: Generic Strategies That Don't Fit Your Business

When an agency takes a one-size-fits-all approach, it often means your business’s unique qualities are being overlooked. Using the same strategy for a local diner, an online retailer, and a B2B tech company doesn’t make sense - each of these businesses operates in a completely different environment with distinct needs.

Every industry has its own customer behaviors and competitive challenges. What works for a yoga studio won’t necessarily succeed for a law firm. Applying identical tactics to businesses with different goals and audiences ignores the nuances that set you apart.

One warning sign to watch for is an agency pitching strategies before they’ve even taken the time to understand your business. If they’re throwing out content ideas or campaign plans during your first meeting - without analyzing your competition, researching your market, or reviewing your customer journey - it’s likely they’re relying on a cookie-cutter playbook. And campaigns built on such a shallow understanding are bound to fall short because they weren’t tailored to your specific needs.

The Pitfalls of Cookie-Cutter Marketing

Generic marketing approaches come with serious downsides. Agencies that simply copy what your competitors are doing often fail to consider your unique position in the market. This lack of originality can dilute your brand’s message, reduce engagement, and leave you struggling to stand out. When your strategy isn’t built with your business in mind, it’s harder to gain a competitive edge.

Why Tailored Campaigns Make a Difference

Custom marketing strategies, on the other hand, are built to align with your specific goals and challenges. A good agency begins with a deep dive into your business. They’ll examine your performance, study your competitors, dig into your target audience’s habits, and fully understand your business model before suggesting any tactics. This process helps uncover opportunities that generic strategies would likely miss.

Tailored campaigns also go beyond just following templates. A strong agency will challenge your assumptions and provide strategic insights, rather than simply executing standard plans. By investing in detailed research and understanding your customer journey, they ensure that every tactic they recommend is designed to drive meaningful results for your business. This kind of personalized approach makes all the difference when it comes to achieving your marketing goals.

Conclusion

Spotting these red flags early can help protect your business from wasting money on ineffective marketing and missing out on growth opportunities. These indicators often reveal when an agency is falling short and mismanaging your budget.

To ensure a productive partnership, focus on a few key principles: transparency, measurable results, and tailored strategies. Your agency should provide clear, detailed reports that break down how your budget is being used and what outcomes it’s delivering. They should maintain open communication, address your concerns promptly, and craft strategies that align with your unique business goals - avoiding one-size-fits-all approaches.

Don’t let underperformance hold you back. Regularly evaluate your partnership by tracking metrics like conversion rates (ideally between 2–5%) and a return on ad spend (ROAS) of at least 4:1, meaning $4 in revenue for every $1 spent. If your agency consistently fails to meet these benchmarks or shows multiple warning signs, it’s time to rethink your strategy. Take a closer look at your metrics and make adjustments to ensure sustainable growth.

At SEO Werkz, we focus on solving these problems through transparent reporting, personalized campaigns, and ongoing performance tracking. Our approach prioritizes open communication and strategies tailored to your specific business needs. If your current agency isn’t delivering the results you deserve, we’re here to help your business achieve the digital marketing success it’s capable of.

FAQs

How can I tell if my digital marketing agency is delivering a good ROI?

To figure out if your digital marketing agency is delivering a good return on investment (ROI), start by comparing the revenue their campaigns generate to the total marketing costs. The formula is straightforward: (Revenue - Marketing Costs) ÷ Marketing Costs.

It's also important that your agency sets clear goals and tracks measurable KPIs that align with what your business wants to achieve - whether that's boosting website traffic, generating leads, or driving more sales. Tools like Google Analytics or your CRM system can help you monitor key metrics such as conversions, customer acquisition costs, and customer lifetime value. By regularly reviewing these numbers, you can see if the results are worth your investment and confirm whether the agency is driving real growth for your business.

How can I improve communication with my digital marketing agency to get better results?

To communicate effectively with your digital marketing agency, it’s crucial to begin by establishing clear goals and expectations right from the start. This ensures everyone is on the same page and working toward the same objectives. Regularly scheduled check-ins or meetings are also essential for reviewing progress, discussing any challenges, and making sure strategies align with your business needs.

Building a strong, collaborative partnership is just as important. Practice active listening during discussions, ask open-ended questions to understand their insights better, and offer constructive feedback when necessary. A transparent and positive approach not only strengthens trust but also paves the way for campaigns that deliver better results.

Why does my business need a customized digital marketing strategy, and what benefits should I expect?

Every business has its own set of goals, audience, and challenges, which is why a customized digital marketing strategy is so important. Relying on a generic, one-size-fits-all approach often means missing the mark, wasting both time and resources.

A tailored strategy ensures your marketing efforts connect with your audience, align with your business goals, and stay relevant to industry trends. This personalized approach not only boosts customer engagement and strengthens brand loyalty but also delivers measurable results. Plus, it ensures your marketing budget is used wisely, leading to better ROI and sustainable growth.

Related posts

• SEO vs PPC: Which Strategy Drives Better ROI?
• Website Redesign: 5 SEO Mistakes to Avoid
• Best SEO Tools for Small Business Owners
• Low Website Traffic: 6 Common Causes & Fixes